The Best Peanut Butter Milkshakes, Easy

Jump to Recipe

Peanut Butter Milkshakes are honestly my favorite after dinner snack to make. I am one of the biggest peanut butter lovers and this is so easy to make using only 3 ingredients.

So I remember making these milkshakes a lot for my dad and I when I was younger and living at home. Recently when he came to visit us here in Canada, I started talking about them and my dad told me a little story. So when he was younger, my grandma and grandpa would go on and on about how he made the best milkshakes around. So of course he loved hearing that and loved to make them for everyone. Turns out that was my grandparents sneaky way of getting out of making dessert. So I started wondering if my dad was doing the same with me! I still haven’t asked him but even if that’s the case, I still love doing it and I think they are pretty dang good.

The best thing is this Peanut Butter Milkshake only takes 3 ingredients to make, more if you like toppings. And I mean, has whipped cream ever made a dessert worse? If so, I can’t think of one! My second favorite thing is that you can add however much, or little peanut butter you like. I like A LOT, but my husband doesn’t like as much so sometimes I pour his, then add more to mine. You can also make it as thick/thin as you like. Just start by adding a little milk and add more as you go.

So all you need for this milkshake is vanilla ice cream, peanut butter and milk. And optional toppings, my favorite is whipped cream. I also like to leave the ice cream in the blender for about 5 minutes before I blend. This just makes the ice cream softer and easier to mix.

Don’t like peanut butter? Try my blackberry cobbler recipe!